Looking for the ultimate burger in Arcadia (or just a short drive away)? You’re in luck. Whether you’re craving a classic cheeseburger with melty cheese, something creatively bold, or a smash-style patty that’s all about flavor, Arcadia and the greater San Gabriel Valley have plenty of burger joints worth your appetite. In this post, we’ll take you through some of the best burger spots within about 30 minutes of Arcadia—places that locals rave about, where the burgers are top notch and the vibe is just right. Let’s sink our teeth into it!
The Derby (Arcadia, CA)
Located right in Arcadia, The Derby is best known as a venerable steakhouse, but locals might be surprised (and delighted) to see their Classic Cheeseburger on the menu. (thederbyarcadia.com) Their lunch menu features “Burgers & Handhelds,” including a Derby Burger and a classic cheeseburger made with sharp cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and that nostalgic 1000 Island dressing. (thederbyarcadia.com) It’s a more upscale environment than your average burger joint—one might say it’s burger meets steakhouse—but that just adds to the experience: it’s a perfect spot for when you want something a little elevated. Plus, The Derby is a local landmark, having served the San Gabriel Valley since 1922. (thederbyarcadia.com)
Eat Fantastic (Arcadia, CA)
If you’re after a burger that feels both casual and crafted, Eat Fantastic is a go-to. Their tagline promises that everything is made “from scratch,” and burger lovers seem to agree. (Eat Fantastic) They serve burgers (and breakfast items) all day, and the menu is loaded with hearty, made-to-order options in a relaxed, no-fuss setting. (Eat Fantastic) Open late (until midnight) and very accessible, it’s a reliable local pick when you want a tasty, straightforward burger close to home. (Yelp)
Patty Meets Bun (Temple City, CA)
A little further out but still within easy reach, Patty Meets Bun brings creativity to the burger scene. Their menu includes standout items like the Chimichurri Burger, Torta Burger, and fusion-inspired options that draw from Latin and Asian influences. (Yelp) Their food truck roots make this place feel like a hidden gem, and fans love that each burger is bold and memorable, not just a standard patty with cheese. (Yelp) If you’re willing to drive a few extra minutes, it’s worth it for a burger that pushes boundaries.
Jim’s Burgers (Arcadia area / nearby)
One name that frequently shows up in burger roundups in and around Arcadia is Jim’s Burgers. (Yelp) While it’s more casual than a steakhouse, Jim’s is beloved for delivering solid, juicy burgers at great value. Its reputation among locals is consistent: simple, dependable, and satisfying. According to Yelp, it ranks among the top burger joints in the area. (Yelp) If your craving is for a classic cheeseburger (or double burger), this is a spot that won’t disappoint.
The Burger Den (Arcadia / nearby)
Another frequent entry in “best burger” lists is The Burger Den. (Yelp) Though it doesn’t always get the same spotlight as Eat Fantastic or Patty Meets Bun, The Burger Den still earns high marks for delivering full-flavored burgers in the neighborhood. It’s a good option when you want something quick, solid, and locally loved.
In-N-Out Burger (Arcadia, CA)
Of course, no burger list would be complete without the classic icon: In-N-Out Burger. With a location right in Arcadia (420 N. Santa Anita) (In-N-Out Burger), this chain needs little introduction—but it counts here because it still offers that reliably good, no-frills burger experience. Their quality control, fresh ingredients, and simple menu make them a fallback favorite. Many locals appreciate having In-N-Out right in town for those times when you want a solid, fast burger fix.
Burger Hop (Pasadena / San Gabriel Valley)
(Note: This one is a bit further out, but still reachable within the greater San Gabriel Valley.) Burger Hop is a burger lounge and bar that mixes fun ambiance with quality burgers and shakes. Though not strictly in Arcadia, it draws fans from across the area who want gourmet patty options, shake pairings, and a social dinner atmosphere. Its menu often includes regional specials and fun twists. If you’re up for a short drive, it can be a fun detour for burger exploration.
Wrap-Up: Bite Into Arcadia’s Best Burgers
Arcadia is more than just a residential suburb — it’s a place with serious burger cred. From Eat Fantastic’s scratch-from-scratch classics to The Derby’s upscale burger touch, and creative flavors at Patty Meets Bun, the burger scene here has something for every style and mood. Add in dependable options like Jim’s Burgers and The Burger Den, plus the local convenience of In-N-Out, and you’ve got plenty of reasons to go on a burger crawl.
So next time you’re in the mood for a juicy patty, cheese pull, crispy fries, and a burger that hits the spot, try one (or all!) on this list. Whether it’s a casual, late-night bite or an elevated burger night out, Arcadia and its surroundings deliver.
And while you’re out exploring flavor, don’t forget to swing by Longo Lexus when you’re looking for exceptional vehicles to match your taste for quality. From luxe sedans to sporty SUVs, Longo Lexus offers models that pair just as well with your lifestyle as your favorite burger pairs with fries. Enjoy the ride—and enjoy the burger hunt!
Connect with us
